Home Schooling | December 6, 2005 |
What do Benjamin Franklin, Abraham Lincoln, Sandra Day O'Connor, and George Abraham Thampy have in common? The answer is that they have all been home schooled. While not a new idea, home schooling is growing in popularity in today's modern world. Home schooling is the fastest growing form of alternative education in the nation. This method of teaching encompasses a diverse group; military families, religious sects, and victims of natural disasters. Many people are under the assumption that home schooling is done mainly by separatist groups that wish to remain isolated from the rest of society. Some home-schoolers may be under the misconception that teaching their children at home will protect them from the evils of society. This research paper will delve into an examination of what is home schooling, offers an explanation as to why so many people are home schooling their children and how they do it. Issues regarding costs, graduation and socialization will be addressed as well. Modern home schooling is an alternative form of education in which school-aged children primarily learn at home, under the supervision of their parents, rather than in traditional school. Home schooling can mean many things depending on the people who choose this alternative. For some it means duplicating school at home, others take the "unschooled approach", allowing their children's interest to determine what they study. Eclectic home-schoolers pick and choose according to their children's needs (Ishizuka, 2000, pp. 3 - 4). There are other forms of alternative education that fall under the direct supervision of school personnel. Examples are independent study programs (ISP) or some kinds of "visiting teacher" programs for the infirm. While these programs may be called "home schooling" and involve the student learning at home, neither the students nor the parents have much control over the content. "Home Study" should not be confused with home schooling. Such programs are offered by school districts so that children confined to home or hospital may keep up with their classmates in school (Zeise, Moxley, 1998). During the 2003-2004 school year one to two million students was home schooled. That accounts for approximately 2 to 4 percent of the school-aged population ("More kids are learning at home," 2005). Home schooled students are growing about 15% a year, according to the U.S. Department of Education (Winters, 2000). Pennsylvania currently has over 25,000 home schooled students. The distribution of home school students in Pennsylvania generally corresponds with population patterns in the state, however the highest concentration of home-schoolers occurs in Lancaster, Berks, and York counties, all counties with very large Amish populations (Vender, 2005). Last year there were 4,430 home schooled students in Philadelphia and its suburbs (Hardy, 2005, pp. B1, B8). Because of frequent relocation, many military families choose the home school alternative for their children. Home schooling is also done for religious reasons by people who want to freely teach their religious values and build strong family bonds. Others choose home schooling for special needs children. Kids with Bi-Polar Disorder, Epilepsy, and Sleep Apnea get the individual attention they need and are not chastised by other children. Perhaps the most important reason people home school is to avoid the nation's public schools. They want to avoid the widespread use of drugs and alcohol consumption, increased teenage sex, and school violence. Home-schoolers should realize that many of these problems are embedded in society and are not isolated to our public schools. Home schooled children also avoid the threat of teacher's strikes, long school bus rides, and increased class size. Many believe that home schooling simply works; home-schoolers are soundly educated and perform well on standardized tests. According to a recent cover story in Time magazine, ". . . the average SAT score for home-schoolers in 2000 was 1100, compared with 1019 for the general population. Today Harvard admissions officers attend home schooling conferences looking for applications, and Rice and Stanford Universities admit home-schoolers at rates equal to or higher than those for public-schoolers (Cloud, Morse, 2001). Some victims of Hurricane Katrina have chosen to home school rather than have their children placed in one of Louisiana's public schools. Formal teaching training for home-schoolers is not necessary. Most home school parents facilitate their children's learning by taking on the role of tutor and providing the tools for their children to learn independently (Ishizuka, 2000, p.31). Home schooling is a legal option in all 50 states but states do regulate the practice. Ten states have no reporting requirements and are considered the most home school friendly; 13 states and Washington D.C. are considered low regulation states only requiring parents to notify the state of their intent to home school; 16 states are considered moderate - regulation and require registration and test scores; and 11 states are considered high regulation, requiring notification, testing and additional measures, such as evaluation by a state-approved educator (Vender, 2005). Pennsylvania is considered a high regulation state with regards to home schooling. In Pennsylvania the compulsory school age is from 8 to 17 years of age. The Pennsylvania Home schooling Act 169-1988 specifies that parents must submit a notarized affidavit of their intent to home school with the local superintendent. Along with this affidavit, they must also submit medical forms and a list of learning objectives covering the required academic subjects. School officials do not have discretionary authority to approve or disapprove a family's home schooling plans. They have the authority to rule on whether the parents have submitted the paperwork required by law. Parents must maintain a portfolio of instruction and daily attendance records, must have at least a high school education, and must arrange for a yearly evaluation of the child's progress by a certified teacher or licensed psychologist of their choosing. At the end of the school year, parents must submit the professional's written evaluation that their child has received an appropriate education along with a portfolio of the child's work for the school district's review. The portfolio must include materials used, work done, annual evaluation and standardized test results. In grades 3, 5, and 8, the home schooled child must take a standardized test, administered by anyone other than the parent of the child (Kanna, Kochenderfer, 2002, p.272). Attendance requires 180 days per year or 900 hours at the elementary level or 990 hours at the secondary level (The Home School Legal Defense Association, 2005). Some home-schoolers like using a curriculum, others do not. Using a curriculum can ensure that the child is covering the same materials as the schools. However, using a curriculum can be restrictive, expensive and time consuming. For those who choose a curriculum there is a wide variety to choose from. Options include computer-based curriculum using teachers at a blackboard to literature-based curriculum incorporating math, civics and reading through classic books (Killingbeck, 2005). The advantages of home schooling allow children to receive a superior education that is attuned specifically to their own needs, learning style, personality, and interests (Kanna, Kochenderfer, 2002, p.14). Families can work at their own pace, this allows children to spend more time on a particular subject or move forward. It also allows for more family time. Some parents have even been able to take their hyperactive ADHD child off Ritalin once they began learning at home (Kanna, Kochenderfer, 2002, p.71). Families can experiment with various curriculums until they find what works best. Learning need not be confined to a classroom; libraries, museums, field trips and the Internet is only a few of the resources available. Home schooling offers a low student-teacher ratio, usually no more than 3 to 1. This can also be counterproductive as a ratio this low limits group discussion and debate. Many people home school for religious reasons. This gives them the advantage of providing their own moral foundation. Other advantages include no more long bus rides to school or mandatory tests. Home schooling is not easy and it requires a lot of work. There are science experiments, field trips, lessons to prepare, and papers to grade. While home schooling itself is not an expensive endeavor compared to private schooling, it can pose limits on one parent's earning potential. Teaching children the more difficult subjects like Chemistry, Geometry, and foreign languages can provide a difficult challenge for most home-schoolers. Some home-schoolers argue that as children become more mature, they become incredibly adept in teaching themselves (Kanna, Kochenderfer, 2002, p.105). While this may be true to some degree, it seems a bit far fetched to expect a child to teach themselves these complex subjects. Many children studying under experts in these fields struggle with these courses. Some families have success using tutors to combat this problem. Socialization is the area cited most often by home schooling critics. Home-schoolers answer the critics of socialization by arguing that most socialization in public schools is negative. Children become preoccupied with materialism and acceptance. Self esteem and independence fostered in the home better prepares children for the outside world. Moreover, most home-schoolers provide their children with a variety of activities, including home school network groups, scouting, church groups, and athletic organizations. The typical home schooled child is involved in over 5 social activities outside the home each week, according to Brian Ray of the National Home Education Research Institute (Ishizuka, 2000, p.17). Recently, the state of Pennsylvania joined 14 other states in mandating that its 25,000 home schooled students be allowed to participate in extracurricular activities, including sports, clubs, and plays (Hardy, 2005, pp. B1, B8). This depends largely on how it is done. Costs are higher if you use an independent study program or boxed curriculum. Complete curriculums can cost from $200 to $500, but many home-schoolers choose this option for their first year. Additional costs include equipment and supplies such as computers, printers, videos, books, paper, pencils, etc (Ishizuka, 2000, pp.73 - 75). Thus, home schooling is usually cheaper than private school but more expensive than public school. Home-schoolers, on the whole, are soundly educated, perform well on standardized tests, go on to attend good colleges and universities and, as adults, thrive variously (Guterson, 1998). In the year 2000 Stanford University accepted 26% of the home-schoolers who applied - nearly double its overall acceptance rate. Home-schoolers scored an average of 1,100 on the SAT - a full 81 points above the national average (Winters, 2000). Home-schoolers placed highest on the SAT college entrance exams in the year 2000, and took first, second, and third place in the 2000 Scripps-Howard national spelling bee. Home-schoolers have had athletic success as well. Coaches are recruiting home schooled athletes, and in 2001 the National Collegiate Athletic Association declared 100 home schooled students eligible for athletics at major universities (Kanna, Kochenderfer, 2002, pp.16 - 17). When it comes to competitions, home-schoolers have the advantage of preparing solely for that particular event. Traditional students must partition their time amongst various subjects. This holds true in athletics as well. The home educator is not locked into any particular system of graduation. For some graduation occurs when they meet the requirements of the independent-study program they are using. Others adopt the requirements of specific schools. Some decide their child has graduated when they are accepted into college. Since most home-schoolers are considered to be private schools, the parents can create their own certificate to serve as a diploma. To the home-schooler graduation is a significant event. Families that participate in home schooling have organized everything from proms to yearbooks. Rings are designed to reflect personal interest, faith, and hobbies. This analysis has offered the opportunity to explore a unique and growing form of alternative education. The opinion that home schooling is done by a minority of people who are out of touch with those in the mainstream has been refuted. Home schooling is a growing trend done by average families all across America. While home schooling offers many merits, it is not for everyone. If not done properly serious damage may occur. It is probably better suited for children at the elementary level. The majority of people will be unable to adequately educate their children at the secondary level due to a lack of subject knowledge. Most adolescents will not be able to school themselves in the higher disciplines of science and mathematics despite strong self interests. For children who are faced with attending an underperforming school, home schooling can be a viable alternative. However, home schooling is not a magic formula for underachievers -- poor performing schooled children will probably not fare well at home either. The reverse is also true. Children who do well in home schooling probably will do just as well in most school environments. The reason home schooling works for some families is that they make it work. When parents take an active interest in their children's education, success is more likely at any form. Public education would be better served if parents displayed the same dedication as those that home school. Being a free nation, we are able to pursue an education of our choice. Without this right George Abraham Thampy may not have become the 2000 Scripps-Howard national spelling bee champion.
Ray Pascali |